Three addresses on U.S. Highway 41 in Wadsworth sit within a hundred numbers of each other: 38905, 38985 and 38995. The first is Wadsworth Inn. It is on the southeast corner of Wadsworth Road and Highway 41, directly south of The Shanty Restaurant. The Shanty is at 38985. Captain Porky's Seafood & BBQ is at 38995 Rt. 41, which its menu page gives as "Hwy. 41 & Wadsworth Road." The three share a family history, and between them their December calendars cover nearly every holiday plan, from an 11 a.m. Christmas Eve lunch to a lobster tail cooked at home.
One family, three doors
Captain Porky's own history has the clearest version of the story. The Kallianis family, raised in a small village in Greece, opened Captain Porky's in Beach Park in the summer of 1986, drawing on the Southern and Creole flavors they found after coming to America. For more than 25 years it served the Beach Park and Zion area. In 2010 it moved to Wadsworth "in partnership with The Shanty Restaurant and The Wadsworth Inn."
The Shanty came first on this corner. Its about page says the Kallianis family began running it in 2006. The restaurant itself has been a neighborhood gathering place for more than 100 years. The Shanty and Wadsworth Inn also keep their calendars in step. On both of their holiday schedules, this year's list starts with the same entry: a staff picnic on Monday, June 1, 2026, when each place kept short hours.
This matters in December because the three places don't compete for the same meal. One is a large, all-day restaurant and event space. One is an evening-only dinner room. One is a seafood counter, smokehouse and caterer that also sells fish raw. Pick by the occasion, and you will rarely need to leave the corner.
The Shanty: the long day and the big table
The Shanty is the biggest of the three and keeps the longest hours. Its contact page lists 11 a.m. to 9 p.m. Monday through Saturday. On Sunday there is breakfast from 8 a.m. to 12:30 p.m., then lunch and dinner from 1 to 9 p.m. It is the only one of the three that serves a Sunday breakfast.
The building has a history of its own. By late 2010, the original part of The Shanty had been rebuilt with reclaimed barnwood from neighborhood farms. In 2018 it tripled in size. The expansion added a 50-seat bar, a 100-seat area around the bar, a 24-seat wine room, a 40-seat balcony, a 24-seat outdoor deck overlooking the forest preserve and a 200-seat private event space. Food Network's Diners, Drive-ins and Dives featured the restaurant in 2010 and again in 2018. The signature dishes it names are Whiskey Shrimp, Tequila Orange Salmon, Apple Brandy Braised Pork Shanks and Organic Goat Cheese Basil Stuffed Wontons. Its about page lists live music on Friday and Saturday nights.
The Shanty's holiday hours for 2026 open earlier than anything else on the block:
- Thanksgiving, Thursday, Nov. 26: closed
- Christmas Eve, Thursday, Dec. 24: 11 a.m. to 8 p.m.
- Christmas Day, Friday, Dec. 25: closed
- New Year's Eve, Thursday, Dec. 31: 11 a.m. to 10 p.m.
- New Year's Day, Friday, Jan. 1, 2027: 11 a.m. to 9 p.m.
On New Year's Eve, The Shanty stays open until 10 p.m., the latest of the three restaurants. On Christmas Eve, it is the only one of the three serving lunch.
For Thanksgiving itself, The Shanty is selling a to-go Thanksgiving dinner for pickup the evening before, Wednesday, Nov. 25, from 4 to 8 p.m. at the east entrance. Orders close at midnight on Monday, Nov. 23, so there are a few days left to order. The family meal, which feeds four, is $140.65 with tax included, and the individual meal is $35.16. Both come with herb butter roasted turkey breast, Parmesan herb mashed potatoes, sage stuffing, gravy made from turkey bone stock, orange zest cranberry sauce, green beans almandine and a kale, pomegranate and apple salad. Butternut squash soup and a pumpkin cheesecake slice are add-ons. At pickup, give the host your online confirmation number.
Wadsworth Inn: dinner, starting at 4
Wadsworth Inn is the evening room. Its about page says it is open seven nights a week starting at 4 p.m. and describes a rustic, casual space with an outdoor balcony and a deck overlooking the forest preserve. The kitchen uses vegetables and herbs from neighborhood farms and cooks its comfort-food entrées in cast iron. The menu also has small plates, fresh seafood and aged steaks. Highlights on the current menu include a warm Maine lobster roll and a shrimp and snow crab boil. The bar menu is built for sharing, with barbecue wings, prime rib flatbread, fried green tomatoes, sliders, fish tacos and meatballs.
The Inn's 2026 holiday hours follow its usual 4 p.m. start. It is closed on Thanksgiving, Thursday, Nov. 26. On Christmas Eve it is open 4 to 8 p.m., and it is closed on Christmas Day. On both New Year's Eve and New Year's Day it is open 4 to 9 p.m.
Set side by side, the two neighbors cover different parts of the holiday. The Shanty's longer day suits a midday Christmas Eve meal or a New Year's Eve dinner that runs late. The Inn's evening hours suit a smaller dinner before people head home. On Jan. 1, The Shanty opens at 11 a.m. for a late breakfast-time crowd, and the Inn opens at 4 p.m. for anyone who would rather not cook the first night of the year.
The Inn also caters, and it asks for orders at least four days before the event. Food arrives in disposable trays or aluminum pans. The Inn doesn't supply chafing dishes or serving utensils, but it will share names of local vendors who rent them.
Captain Porky's: the one that sends you home to cook
Captain Porky's covers the meals you would rather make at home. Its menu page says it has supplied home cooks with fresh and frozen seafood for three decades. Every item on the menu is available raw to cook at home, and customers can pick from the seasonal seafood on hand each day or special-order their favorites from almost anywhere in the world. For anyone planning a seafood Christmas Eve at home, the fish can come from Wadsworth.
The catering side goes further. Its seafood trays come in two sizes, with prices for each:
- Boiled shrimp cocktail: $60 or $120
- Smoked salmon: $70 or $140
- Snow crab legs: $90 or $180
- King crab legs: market price
- Cold water lobster tail: $32.99 for a half pound, $54.99 for a full pound
- Raw oysters: $24.99 a dozen
The dessert trays include baklava, chocolate chip bread pudding and turtle cheesecake, and a key lime pie is $17.99. If you need serving gear, Captain Porky's rents stainless chafing dishes for $20 each, with stand and heaters included. They are due back within 36 hours of the event. Like the Inn, it asks for four days' notice on catering orders. A tray for a Christmas Eve gathering should be ordered by about Dec. 20.
The hot food is cooked on site. Seafood is made to order, breaded, pan-seared or steamed. The barbecue is smoked every day over hickory and cherry wood in an Aquarium Smoker Pit custom-built in Chicago. The posted hours are 10 a.m. to 8 p.m., Monday through Sunday, for dine-in, carryout and catering. Before driving over on Dec. 24, Dec. 31 or the holidays themselves, call 847-360-7460 to check that day's hours.
Before and after the block
On Route 41, the rest of Wadsworth's dining is mostly drive-through. McDonald's is at 39105 U.S. Hwy 41, a little north of the corner. Dunkin' has two Wadsworth locations, one at 39090 N. U.S. Highway 41 and one at 16145 W. Highway 173, and both list daily hours and drive-through service. Farther north, the Arby's at 43100 U.S. Hwy 41 lists 24-hour service. That matters on Christmas Day, when The Shanty and Wadsworth Inn are both closed.
For cookie trays and party favors, A Unique Cookie is a Wadsworth business that takes custom cookie orders through its own order form. The Village of Wadsworth's business directory also lists Oaks Duck Inn at 15225 W. Wadsworth Road and Tracy's Bistro at 41869 N. U.S. Highway 41.
Put it all on one calendar and the corner of Route 41 and Wadsworth Road covers most of the season. Captain Porky's has fish and trays for a Christmas Eve at home, with catering orders in four days ahead. The Shanty has lunch that day starting at 11 a.m. Wadsworth Inn has dinner from 4 to 8 p.m. On New Year's Eve, The Shanty stays open until 10 p.m.
If your holidays this year include hosting family in a new place, or wondering whether next December should be spent closer to Route 41, Team Pimentel is glad to talk it through. Start with our Wadsworth neighborhood page, and when you're ready, we'll give you honest, no-pressure answers. Work With Us.